If you're considering purchasing a MacBook Pro 2017 or Refurbished MacBook Pro 2017, you may be tempted by its low price, especially as it's available for around $300. But does it still hold up in 2024? Let’s look at the details and whether it’s worth your investment.
MacOS 15 Sequoia Support: No Longer Available
The MacBook Pro 2017 no longer supports the latest MacOS 15 Sequoia, released in September 2024. This means you’ll be missing out on critical security updates, new features, and compatibility with some modern applications. Without ongoing software support, this model’s lifespan is limited, making it a less appealing choice for long-term use.
Price: Starting at $300+
The Refurbished MacBook Pro 2017 can be found for as low as $300, a considerable discount from its original launch price of $1,299. While the price seems attractive, you should consider the long-term performance and support limitations before purchasing. Spending a little more upfront could save you from needing an upgrade sooner than expected.
The Same Old Story: Keyboard Issues
Much like the MacBook Pro 2018, the MacBook Pro 2017 also suffers from Apple’s problematic butterfly keyboard. This keyboard design has been widely criticized for its lack of durability and issues with dust and debris, leading to frequent malfunctions. This design flaw adds a layer of risk to purchasing this model. If you're looking for a reliable machine for daily use, this could be a dealbreaker.
Our Recommendation: The MacBook Pro 2020
Given the MacBook Pro 2020 is available for $500+, we recommend spending the extra money to get the newer model. The 2020 MacBook Pro not only offers better performance, but it also comes with the Magic Keyboard, which solved the reliability issues of the previous butterfly keyboards. Furthermore, it features newer processors and will enjoy longer software support, making it a better long-term investment.
Comparison of MacBook Pro 2017 vs. MacBook Pro 2020
| Specification |
MacBook Pro 2017 |
MacBook Pro 2020 |
| Chipset |
Intel Core i5/i7 7th Gen |
Intel Core i5/i7 10th Gen / Apple M1 |
| Display |
13.3" Retina, 2560x1600, True Tone |
13.3" Retina, 2560x1600, True Tone |
| Keyboard |
Butterfly keyboard (prone to issues) |
Magic keyboard (reliable) |
| Battery |
10 hours |
10 hours |
| USB Ports |
4 Thunderbolt 3 (USB-C) |
4 Thunderbolt 3 (USB-C) |
| Size & Weight |
0.59" thick, 3.02 lbs |
0.61" thick, 3.0 lbs |
| Memory & Storage |
8GB to 16GB RAM, 256GB to 1TB SSD |
8GB to 16GB RAM, 256GB to 2TB SSD |
| Price |
$300+ (used/refurbished) |
$500+ (used/refurbished) |
Chipset
The MacBook Pro 2017 features Intel’s 7th generation Core i5 or i7 processors, which, while functional, are significantly slower than the 10th generation Intel chips or Apple’s M1 chip found in the MacBook Pro 2020. The newer processors not only offer better performance but also enhanced power efficiency, making the MacBook Pro 2020 a superior choice for multitasking, video editing, and running modern applications.
Display
Both the MacBook Pro 2017 and MacBook Pro 2020 models have a 13.3-inch Retina display with a resolution of 2560x1600 and True Tone technology. The display on both models is excellent, with vibrant colors and crisp details. However, since there’s no significant difference in this category, the decision will come down to other features like performance and reliability.
Keyboard
As with the 2018 model, the MacBook Pro 2017 uses the butterfly keyboard, notorious for its unreliability. On the other hand, the MacBook Pro 2020 features the Magic Keyboard, which offers a far more reliable and comfortable typing experience. For this reason, the 2020 model is the clear winner if you’re concerned about long-term usability.
Battery
Both models boast a battery life of around 10 hours, but the M1 chip in the MacBook Pro 2020 delivers better power efficiency. This means that, especially with heavy usage, the 2020 model is more likely to maintain battery performance over time.
USB Ports
Both the MacBook Pro 2017 and MacBook Pro 2020 come with four Thunderbolt 3 (USB-C) ports, so there’s no significant difference when it comes to connectivity options.
Size & Weight
There is very little difference in terms of portability between the two models. The MacBook Pro 2017 is slightly thinner at 0.59 inches compared to 0.61 inches for the MacBook Pro 2020, but both are lightweight and easy to carry, making them great options for on-the-go use.
Memory & Storage
The MacBook Pro 2017 is available with 8GB to 16GB of RAM and 256GB to 1TB of SSD storage, which is quite similar to the configurations available for the MacBook Pro 2020. However, the 2020 model offers higher storage options, going up to 2TB of SSD storage, making it a better choice if you need more space for large files or creative projects.
Price
The MacBook Pro 2017 is available for $300+ and the MacBook Pro 2020 starts at $500+. With a price gap of around $200, the MacBook Pro 2020 offers better value with its superior performance, reliability, and longer software support.
Used vs. Certified Used/Refurbished
When buying a Used MacBook Pro, it’s important to understand the difference between standard used devices and Certified Used or Refurbished models. A standard used MacBook Pro may come without any warranties or guarantees regarding its condition. On the other hand, Certified Refurbished models go through professional inspections, repairs, and cleaning, ensuring they meet manufacturer standards. These devices also typically come with warranties, providing peace of mind.
Opting for a Certified Used or Refurbished MacBook Pro adds assurance in terms of quality and reliability, minimizing the risk of potential issues compared to buying a standard used laptop.
About UpTrade
At UpTrade, we make buying used and refurbished tech simple and risk-free. Our platform lets you compare prices from trusted sellers like Apple, Amazon, and BestBuy, ensuring you get the best deal on your next device. By focusing on Certified Used and Refurbished products, we offer a reliable, cost-effective way to shop for high-quality tech without the risks often associated with buying used devices. Whether you're interested in the MacBook Pro 2017 or MacBook Pro 2020, UpTrade helps you find great deals with ease.
Final Verdict
While the MacBook Pro 2017 is available for a lower price, the keyboard issues, lack of support for the latest MacOS, and performance limitations make it less appealing. For around $200 more, the MacBook Pro 2020 offers better reliability, performance, and long-term value. If you're in the market for a used MacBook, it’s worth spending the extra money for the newer model.
You can compare prices for Certified Used MacBook Pro 2020 from sellers like Apple, Amazon, and BestBuy on UpTrade to find the best deal.
